Monday, June 4, 2012
Roxanne Quimby Case Study
Eric Porter
Roxanne Quimby Case Study
B283
Case Analysis
Introduction:
Roxanne Quimby grew up in an entrepreneurial family. She was taught a lot of self-reliance which came in handy
when, through some choices her father didn’t approve of, she was disowned and left to fend completely on her own. She
found a bee keeper named Burt Shavitz who was just as broke as she was. They decided to team up, applying her
creativity to Burt’s honey and bees wax. It was a hit and everybody wanted their supplies from candles to lip balm
across all 50 states.
With increasing demand Roxanne didn’t believe they had any more room to grow in Maine. In an attempt to make room for
more growth her and Burt purchased a small factory space in North Carolina where they hoped to increase their efficiency
as well as their customer relations. However the move brought with it more growing pains that Roxanne had imagined.
Problem Analysis:
-Major problems and challenges facing employees and organization:
The employee culture is cheap in Maine and unskilled while the employee culture in North Carolina is very factory
skilled but not cheap. It will probably cost the same to pay one employee in North Carolina as it would cost to pay
three in Maine. This is a step out of her comfort zone because for Roxanne, she can do the labor intensive candle
shaping, dipping, wax blending work, yet she cannot work the machinery.
There is also the critical decision of what products will they continue and what not.
Roxanne brings a good point that the work culture is very different. I don’t, however, believe
that her options are that limited. Every place has unskilled workers somewhere and she could
attempt to continue her line of candle making. Though I do see her point that it is more efficient
to use machines and while hand sculpting candles is profitable, it is very labor intensive. This
could partly be solved by leaving a small branch of the store open in Maine where people know
what to do and can continue doing what they do best which would bring in money while
Roxanne attempts to expand the business into North Carolina.
Recommendations:
Some recommendations are too late to change, but if I were moving my entire company I would put way more
planning into it before actually moving. Like what products will I make when I get there? Is the factory adequately
equipped for our business? How many employees will we need once we move down there? These and many more questions I
would have asked that Roxanne didn’t seem to think through very much.
Conclusion:
In the end Roxanne offers three futures for her business. To move back to Maine and live with the issues they are
currently dealing with. They could stay in North Carolina and try to make it work, even with all the changes they may
need to undergo. The final option is selling the business completely and moving onto another venture and another dream
in India selling various fashions and crafts. Of the three I completely believe that she should work it out in North
Carolina. I believe that she should have made a few more preparations in the move rather than laying off everybody and
moving before everything was ready in North Carolina; however she is simply taking the easy road out.
Roxanne speaks of freedom being her biggest desire for even starting the company. She wanted to be free from
accountability and this business would in many ways tie her down. There is so much potential in the company though that
I think she lost a lot of her vision for the company, if she ever had a vision for it. She often calls the business her
child and that eventually a child grows up and leaves its mother. Now that the business is just getting into high
school and can start playing with the big boys, she fears the extra work and commitment it will take to get it
prepared. However it is obvious that she can make it work and grow in North Carolina.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment